张中祥;王梦佳奇;

• 1:天津大学马寅初经济学院
• 2:国家能源、环境和产业经济研究院

摘要(Abstract)：

本文以2010～2019年社会资本参与的“一带一路”45个国家1293个能源投资项目为研究样本，探究可再生能源政策吸引社会资本绿色投资的有效性。实证结果表明：一国可再生能源政策可以显著促进社会资本做出绿色投资决策并增加投资规模。区分可再生能源发展阶段的回归结果显示，可再生能源政策对社会资本绿色投资的吸引作用仅体现在处于起步期的可再生能源市场，而当市场处于成长成熟期后，融资市场成为社会资本绿色投资的主要驱动力。可再生能源政策可能通过推动可再生能源市场开拓来影响社会资本绿色投资规模，但对可再生能源技术创新的促进效应暂未显现。因此，推动“一带一路”绿色发展，不仅要优化国家可再生能源政策体系，而且要充分拓宽可再生能源领域融资渠道。

关键词(KeyWords)： “一带一路”;可再生能源政策;社会资本;绿色投资

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金重大项目“贸易壁垒下突破性创新政策体系构建研究”（批准号：20&ZD109）;; 国家自然科学基金重大项目“绿色低碳发展转型中的关键管理科学问题与政策研究”子课题“国际气候治理与合作机制研究”（批准号：71690243）~~

作者(Authors): 张中祥;王梦佳奇;

DOI: 10.19602/j.chinaeconomist.2023.03.05

参考文献(References)：

• [1] Almulhim, A. I. 2022.“Understanding Public Awareness and Attitudes toward Renewable Energy Resources in Saudi Arabia.” Renewable Energy, 192:572-582.
• [2] Barradale, M.J. 2010.“Impact of Public Policy Uncertainty on Renewable Energy Investment:Wind Power and the Production Tax Credit.” Energy Policy, 38(12):7698-7709.
• [3] Berry, T., and M Jaccard. 2001.“The Renewable Portfolio Standard:Design Considerations and An Implementation Survey.” Energy Policy, 29(4):263-277.
• [4] Bird, L., M. Bolinger, T. Gagliano, R. Wiser, M. Brown, and B. Parsons. 2005.“Policies and Market Factors Driving Wind Power Development in the United States.” Energy Policy, 33(11):1397-1407.
• [5] Carley, S. 2009.“State Renewable Energy Electricity Policies:An Empirical Evaluation of Effectiveness.” Energy Policy,37(8):3071-3081.
• [6] Cheng S., and S. Qi. 2021.“The Potential for China’s Outward Foreign Direct Investment and Its Determinants:A Comparative Study of Carbon-intensive and Non-carbon-intensive Sectors Along the Belt and Road.” Journal of Environmental Management, 282:111960.
• [7] ClimateWorks Foundation. 2019.“Decarbonizing the Belt and Road”, https://www.climateworks.org/.
• [8] Cong, R.G., and Y. M. Wei. 2010.“Potential Impact of(CET)Carbon Emissions Trading on China’s Power Sector:A Perspective from Different Allowance Allocation Options.” Energy, 35(9):3921-3931.
• [9] Dong, C.G. 2012.“Feed-in Tariff vs. Renewable Portfolio Standard:An Empirical Test of Their Relative Effectiveness in Promoting Wind Capacity Development.” Energy Policy, 42:476-485.
• [10] Egli, F., B Steffen, and T. S Schmidt. 2019.“Learning in the Financial Sector Is Essential for Reducing Renewable Energy Costs.” Nature Energy, 4(10):835-836.
• [11] Friedemann, P., M. Michael, A. T. Florian, and P. Von Flotow. 2015.“Public Policy Influence on Renewable Energy Investments—A Panel Data Study across OECD Countries.” Energy Policy, 80:98-111.
• [12] Gan, L., G.S. Eskeland, and H.H Kolshus. 2007.“Green Electricity Market Development:Lessons from Europe and the US.” Energy Policy, 35(1):144-155.
• [13] Hashemizadeh, A., Y. Ju., S. M. H. Bamakan, H. Lund, and M. J. Kaiser. 2021.“Renewable Energy Investment Risk Assessment in Belt and Road Initiative Countries under Uncertainty Conditions.” Energy, 214:118923.
• [14] International Energy Agency. 2016.“Re-powering Markets:Market Design and Regulation during the Transition to Lowcarbon Power Systems”.
• [15] International Renewable Energy Agency. 2019.“Renewable Energy Auctions:Status and Trends beyond Price”.
• [16] Ji, Q., and D Zhang. 2019.“How Much does Financial Development Contribute to Renewable Energy Growth and Upgrading of Energy Structure in China?” Energy Policy, 128:114-124.
• [17] Kersey, J., P Blechinger, and R Shirley. 2021.“A Panel Data Analysis of Policy Effectiveness for Renewable Energy Expansion on Caribbean Islands.” Energy Policy, 155:112340.
• [18] Kim, J.E. 2020.“Regulation Trumps Economics? Examining Renewable Energy Policy, Diffusion and Investment in 80Developing Countries.” Energy Research&Social Science, 70:101613.
• [19] Kim, J., and K. Park. 2016.“Financial Development and Deployment of Renewable Energy Technologies.” Energy Economics, 59:238-250.
• [20] Liu, H., Y. Wang, J. Jiang, and P. Wu. 2020.“How Green Is the “Belt and Road Initiative”?–Evidence from Chinese OFDI in the Energy Sector.” Energy Policy, 145:111709.
• [21] Maianne, F., M. David, and S. Stephane. 2021.“Funding and Financing Infrastructure:The Joint-use of Public and Private Finance.” Journal of Development Economics, 150:102629.
• [22] Marques, A. C., J. A. Fuinhas, and J. R. Pires Manso. 2010.“Motivations Driving Renewable Energy in European Countries:A Panel Data Approach.” Energy Policy, 38(11):6877-6885.
• [23]?zdemir,?., B. F. Hobbs, M. Van Hout, and P. Koutstaal. 2020.“Capacity vs Energy Subsidies for Promoting Renewable Investment:Benefits and Costs for the EU Power Market.” Energy Policy, 137:111-166.
• [24] Patricia, G, and M Francesca. 2010.“Does the Political and Economic Context Influence the Success of a Transport Project? An Analysis of Transport Public-private Partnerships.” Research in Transportation Economics, 30(1):102-109.
• [25] Polzin, F., F. Egli, B. Steffen, and Schmidt T. S. 2019.“How Do Policies Mobilize Private Finance for Renewable Energy?—A Systematic Review with an Investor Perspective.” Applied Energy, 236:1249-1268.
• [26] Rogge, K.S., and V. H Hoffmann. 2010.“The Impact of the EU ETS on the Sectoral Innovation System for Power Generation Technologies—Findings for Germany.” Energy Policy, 38(12):7639-7652.
• [27] Romano, A. A, G. Scandurra, A. Carfora, and M. Fodor. 2017.“Renewable Investments:The Impact of Green Policies in Developing and Developed Countries.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 68:738-747.
• [28] Shahbaz, M., S Khan, and M.I Tahir. 2013.“The Dynamic Links between Energy Consumption, Economic Growth,Financial Development and Trade in China:Fresh Evidence from Multivariate Framework Analysis.” Energy Economics,40:8-21.
• [29] Surana, K., and L.D Anadon 2015 “Public Policy and Financial Resource Mobilization for Wind Energy in Developing Countries:A Comparison of Approaches and Outcomes in China and India.” Global Environmental Change, 35:340-359.
• [30] Terrados, J., G. Almonacid, and L. Hontoria. 2007.“Regional Energy Planning through SWOT Analysis and Strategic Planning Tools.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 11(6):1275-1287.
• [31] Tsvetanov, T. 2019.“When the Carrot Goes Bad:The Effect of Solar Rebate Uncertainty.” Energy Economics, 81:886-898.
• [32] World Economic Forum. 2022.“Global Risks Report 2022”, https://www.weforum.org/reports/global-risks-report-2022.
• [33] Zarnikau, J. 2011.“Successful Renewable Energy Development in a Competitive Electricity Market:A Texas Case Study.”Energy Policy, 39(7):3906-3913.
• [34] Zhao, Y., K. K. Tang, and L.Wang. 2013.“Do Renewable Electricity Policies Promote Renewable Electricity Generation?Evidence from Panel Data.” Energy Policy, 62:887-897.
• [35]曹翔、滕聪波、张继军，2020，《“一带一路”倡议对沿线国家环境质量的影响》，《中国人口·资源与环境》第12期。
• [36]仇娟东、黄海楠、马赫然，2021，《多边金融机构如何影响PPP项目中私人部门的投资额?——来自“一带一路”沿线经济体3858个项目的经验证据》，《中国软科学》第01期。
• [37]邓忠奇、陈甬军，2018，《“一带一路”背景下融资方公私合营模式的资本结构分析》，《产业经济研究》第03期。
• [38]范英、衣博文，2021，《能源转型的规律、驱动机制与中国路径》，《管理世界》第08期。
• [39]龚强、张一林、雷丽衡，2019，《政府与社会资本合作(PPP):不完全合约视角下的公共品负担理论》，《经济研究》第04期。
• [40]贺炎林、张杨、范言慧，2021，《经验、产业集聚与“一带一路”PPP项目的成功率》，《国际经贸探索》第03期。
• [41]李昕蕾，2020，《德国、美国、日本、印度的清洁能源外交比较研究:兼论对中国绿色“一带一路”建设的启示》，《中国软科学》第07期。
• [42]刘钻扩、辛丽，2018，《“一带一路”建设对沿线中国重点省域绿色全要素生产率的影响》，《中国人口·资源与环境》第12期。
• [43]罗煜、王芳、陈熙，2017，《制度质量和国际金融机构如何影响PPP项目的成效——基于“一带一路”46国经验数据的研究》，《金融研究》第04期。
• [44]马丽梅、黄崇乐，2022，《金融驱动与可再生能源发展——基于跨国数据的动态演化分析》，《中国工业经济》第04期。
• [45]齐绍洲、林屾、崔静波，2018，《环境权益交易市场能否诱发绿色创新?——基于我国上市公司绿色专利数据的证据》，《经济研究》第12期。
• [46]齐绍洲、张振源，2019，《欧盟碳排放权交易、配额分配与可再生能源技术创新》，《世界经济研究》第09期。
• [47]孙佑海，2017，《绿色“一带一路”环境法规制研究》，《中国法学》第06期。
• [48]吴力波、孙可哿、陈亚龙，2015，《不完全竞争电力市场中可再生能源支持政策比较》，《中国人口·资源与环境》第10期。
• [49]徐哲潇、杜国臣，2018，《以PPP模式推动“一带一路”建设的思考》，《国际经济合作》第10期。
• [50]徐奇渊、杨盼盼、肖立晟，2017，《“一带一路”投融资机制建设:中国如何更有效地参与》，《国际经济评论》第05期。
• [51]杨波、李波，2021，《“一带一路”倡议与企业绿色转型升级》，《国际经贸探索》第06期。
• [52]张琦、郑瑶、孔东民，2019，《地区环境治理压力、高管经历与企业环保投资——一项基于<环境空气质量标准(2012)>的准自然实验》，《经济研究》第06期。
• [53]张金珠、尤雪鹏、刘宇、田园，2021，《基础设施OFDI对东道国的经济与环境影响——以“一带一路”六大经济走廊重点国家为例》，《国际经济合作》第05期。
• [1] Cao, Xiang, Congbo Teng, and Jijun Zhang. 2020.“BRI’s Effects on Environmental Quality in BRI Countries.” Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment, 12:116-124.
• [2] Qiu, Juandong, Hainan Huang, and Heran Ma. 2021.“How Did Multinational Financial Institutions Influence Private Sector Investment in PPP Projects? Empirical Evidence from 3,858 Project in BRI Economies.” China Soft Science, 1:85-97.
• [3] Deng, Zhongqi, and Yongjun Chen. 2018.“Analysis of Capital Structure of Private-Public Partnership(PPP)for Financing Parties in the Context of BRI.” Industrial Economics Research, 3:90-102.
• [4] Fan, Ying, and Bowen Yi. 2021.“Patterns, Driving Mechanisms and Chinese Pathways for the Energy Transition.”Management World, 8:95-105.
• [5] Gong, Qiang, Yilin Zhang, and Liheng Lei. 2019.“Public-Private Partnership(PPP):Theory of Public Goods Burden from the Perspective of Incomplete Contracts.” Economic Research Journal, 4:133-148.
• [6] He, Yanlin, Yang Zhang, and Yanhui Fan. 2021.“Experiences, Industrial Agglomeration and Success Rates of BRI PPP Projects.” International Economics and Trade Research, 3:47-64.
• [7] Li, Xinlei. 2020.“Comparative Research on Clean Energy Diplomacy:Inspirations for China’s Green BRI.” China Soft Science, 7:1-15.
• [8] Liu, Zuankuo, and Li Xin. 2018.“BRI’s Effects on Green TFP in Major Chinese Provinces Involved.” Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment, 12:87-97.
• [9] Luo, Yu, Fang Wang, and Xi Chen. 2017.“How Will Institutional Quality and International Financial Institutions Influence the Outcomes of PPP Projects:Study Based on the Empirical Data of 46 BRI Countries.” Journal of Financial Research, 4:61-77.
• [10] Ma, Limei, and Chongle Huang. 2022.“Financial Impetus and Renewable Energy Development:Dynamic Evolution Analysis Based on Cross-National Data.” China Industrial Economics, 4:118-136.
• [11] Qi, Shaozhou, Shen Lin, and Jingbo Cui. 2018.“Will Environment Equity Transaction Markets Trigger Green Innovation?Evidence Based on the Green Patent Data of China’s Listed Companies.” Economic Research Journal, 12:129-143.
• [12] Qi, Shaozhou, and Zhenyuan Zhang. 2019.“EU’s Carbon Trading, Quota Distribution and Renewable Energy Technological Innovation.” World Economy Studies, 9:119-133.
• [13] Sun, Youhai. 2017.“Study on Environmental Regulation for Green BRI.” China Legal Science, 6:110-128.
• [14] Wu, Libo, Kege Sun, and Yalong Chen. 2015.“Comparison of Renewable Energy Support Policies in the Electric Power Market of Imperfect Competition.” Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment, 10:53-60.
• [15] Xu, Zhexiao, and Guochen Du. 2018.“Reflections on BRI Development under the PPP Mode.” Journal of International Economic Cooperation, 10:61-66.
• [16] Xu, Qiyuan, Panpan Yang, and Lisheng Xiao. 2017.“Development Financing Mechanisms under the BRI:Ways for China’s More Effective Participation.” International Economic Review, 5:134-148.
• [17] Yang, Bo, and Bo Li. 2021.“BRI and Corporate Green Transition.” International Economics and Trade Research, 6:20-36.
• [18] Zhang, Qi, Yao Zheng, and Dongmin Kong. 2019.“Regional Environmental Governance Pressures, Senior Executive Experiences and Firm Environmental Protection Investment:A Quasi-Natural Experiment Based on the Environmental Air Quality Standards(2012), Economic Research Journal, 6:183-198.
• [19] Zhang, Jinzhu, Xuepeng You, Yu Liu, and, Yuan Tian. 2021.“Economic and Environmental Effects of Infrastructure OFDI for Host Countries:An Example of Key Countries Six BRI Economic Corridors.” Journal of International Economic Cooperation, 5:53-63.
• [20] Almulhim, A. I. 2022.“Understanding Public Awareness and Attitudes Toward Renewable Energy Resources in Saudi Arabia.” Renewable Energy, 192:572-582.
• [21] Barradale, M. J. 2010.“Impact of Public Policy Uncertainty on Renewable Energy Investment:Wind Power and the Production Tax Credit.” Energy Policy, 38(12):7698-7709.
• [22] Berry, T., and M. Jaccard. 2001.“The Renewable Portfolio Standard:Design Considerations and An Implementation Survey.” Energy Policy, 29(4):263-277.
• [23] Bird, L., M. Bolinger, T. Gagliano, R. Wiser, M. Brown, and B. Parsons. 2005.“Policies and Market Factors Driving Wind Power Development in the United States.” Energy Policy, 33(11):1397-1407.
• [24] Carley, S. 2009.“State Renewable Energy Electricity Policies:An Empirical Evaluation of Effectiveness.” Energy Policy,37(8):3071-3081.
• [25] Cheng, S., and S. Qi. 2021.“The Potential for China’s Outward Foreign Direct Investment and Its Determinants:A Comparative Study of Carbon-intensive and Non-carbon-intensive Sectors along the Belt and Road.” Journal of Environmental Management, 282:111960.
• [26] ClimateWorks Foundation. 2019.“Decarbonizing the Belt and Road”.
• [27] Cong, R. G., and Y. M. Wei. 2010.“Potential Impact of(CET)Carbon Emissions Trading on China’s Power Sector:A Perspective from Different Allowance Allocation Options.” Energy, 35(9):3921-3931.
• [28] Dong, C. G. 2012.“Feed-in Tariff vs. Renewable Portfolio Standard:An Empirical Test of Their Relative Effectiveness in Promoting Wind Capacity Development.” Energy Policy, 42:476-485.
• [29] Egli, F., B. Steffen, and T.S. Schmidt. 2019.“Learning in the Financial Sector Is Essential for Reducing Renewable Energy Costs.” Nature Energy, 4(10):835-836.
• [30] Friedemann, P., M. Michael, A. T. Florian, and P. Von Flotow. 2015.“Public Policy Influence on Renewable Energy Investments-A Panel Data Study across OECD Countries.” Energy Policy, 80:98-111.
• [31] Gan, L., G.S. Eskeland, and H. H. Kolshus. 2007.“Green Electricity Market Development:Lessons from Europe and the US.” Energy Policy, 35(1):144-155.
• [32] Hashemizadeh, A., Y. Ju., S. M. H. Bamakan, H. Lund, and M. J. Kaiser. 2021.“Renewable Energy Investment Risk Assessment in Belt and Road Initiative Countries under Uncertainty Conditions.” Energy, 214:118923.
• [33] International Energy Agency. 2016.“Re-powering Markets:Market Design and Regulation during the Transition to Lowcarbon Power Systems”.
• [34] International Renewable Energy Agency. 2019.“Renewable Energy Auctions:Status and Trends beyond Price”.
• [35] Ji, Q., and D. Zhang. 2019.“How Much Does Financial Development Contribute to Renewable Energy Growth and Upgrading of Energy Structure in China?” Energy Policy, 128:114-124.
• [36] Kersey, J., P. Blechinger, and R. Shirley. 2021.“A Panel Data Analysis of Policy Effectiveness for Renewable Energy Expansion on Caribbean Islands.” Energy Policy, 155:112340.
• [37] Kim, J. E. 2020.“Regulation Trumps Economics? Examining Renewable Energy Policy, Diffusion and Investment in 80Developing Countries.” Energy Research&Social Science, 70:101613.
• [38] Kim, J., and K. Park. 2016.“Financial Development and Deployment of Renewable Energy Technologies.” Energy Economics, 59. 238-250.
• [39] Liu, H., Y. Wang, J. Jiang, and P. Wu. 2020.“How Green Is the ‘Belt and Road Initiative’”?–Evidence from Chinese OFDI in the Energy Sector.” Energy Policy, 145:111709.
• [40] Maianne, F., M. David, and S. Stephane. 2021.“Funding and Financing Infrastructure:The Joint-use of Public and Private Finance.” Journal of Development Economics, 150:102629.
• [41] Marques, A. C., J. A. Fuinhas, and J. R. Pires Manso. 2010.“Motivations Driving Renewable Energy in European Countries:A Panel Data Approach.” Energy Policy, 38(11):6877-6885.
• [42]?zdemir,?., B. F. Hobbs, M. Van Hout, and P. Koutstaal. 2020.“Capacity vs Energy Subsidies for Promoting Renewable Investment:Benefits and Costs for the EU Power Market.” Energy Policy, 137:111166.
• [43] Patricia, G, and M Francesca. 2010.“Does the Political and Economic Context Influence the Success of a Transport Project? An Analysis of Transport Public-private Partnerships.” Research in Transportation Economics, 30(1):102-109.
• [44] Polzin, F., F. Egli, B. Steffen, and Schmidt T. S. 2019.“How do Policies Mobilize Private Finance for Renewable Energy?-A Systematic Review with an Investor Perspective.” Applied Energy, 236:1249-1268.
• [45] Rogge, K. S., and V. H Hoffmann. 2010.“The Impact of the EU ETS on the Sectoral Innovation System for Power Generation Technologies–Findings for Germany.” Energy Policy, 38(12):7639-7652.
• [46] Romano, A. A, G. Scandurra, A. Carfora, and M. Fodor. 2017.“Renewable Investments:The Impact of Green Policies in Developing and Developed Countries.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 68:738-747.
• [47] Shahbaz, M., S. Khan, and M. I. Tahir. 2013.“The Dynamic Links between Energy Consumption, Economic Growth,Financial Development and Trade in China:Fresh Evidence from Multivariate Framework Analysis.” Energy Economics,40:8-21.
• [48] Surana, K., and L.D. Anadon. 2015 “Public Policy and Financial Resource Mobilization for Wind Energy in Developing Countries:A Comparison of Approaches and Outcomes in China and India.” Global Environmental Change, 35:340-359.
• [49] Terrados, J., G. Almonacid, and L. Hontoria. 2007.“Regional Energy Planning through SWOT Analysis and Strategic Planning Tools.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 11(6):1275-1287.
• [50] Tsvetanov, T. 2019.“When the Carrot Goes Bad:The Effect of Solar Rebate Uncertainty.” Energy Economics, 81:886-898.
• [51] World Economic Forum,.2022.“Global Risks Report 2022”.
• [52] Zarnikau, J. 2011.“Successful Renewable Energy Development in a Competitive Electricity Market:A Texas Case Study.”Energy Policy, 39(7):3906-3913.
• [53] Zhao, Y., K. K. Tang, and L. Wang. 2013.“Do Renewable Electricity Policies Promote Renewable Electricity Generation?Evidence from Panel Data.” Energy Policy, 62:887-897.